Drinking from cracked cisterns – the Christian life and the new millennium

Alison Morgan, Holy Trinity, January 2000

Jeremiah 2.1-28

 

Introduction

 

He who has an ear, let him hear what the Spirit says to the churches.

Behold, I stand at the door and knock; if any one hears my voice and opens the door, I will come in to him and eat with him, and he with me. He who conquers, I will grant him to sit with me on my throne.

 

We all know that verse. We use it as a picture of God’s call to the individual. It comes from the book of Revelation, and it was written by the prophet John at the beginning of the first millennium. But actually John wasn’t writing to an individual, which is how we usually take that verse. He was writing to a church, and like most prophets he wrote with both words of hope and words of warning.

 

And I would like to suggest that as we stand here on the threshhold of a new millennium we too find ourselves standing before words of hope and words of warning.  We have a choice. We can go two ways. We can settle back into our bright new armchairs, the armchairs of technological progress, and shut out the horrors of the two world wars of what I can now call the last century. We can congratulate ourselves on our brave new world and relax into our comfortable materialism. Or we can dare to look beneath the glittering surface, dare face up to the disturbing aspects of our world, and dare to listen to a disturbing God through the disturbing words of his disturbing prophets.

 

For John’s word to the churches was not all glory and triumph. This was the warning:

 

For you say, I am rich, I have prospered, and I need nothing; not knowing that you are wretched, pitiable, poor, blind and naked. Therefore I counsel you to buy from me gold refined by fire, that you may be rich, and white garments to clothe you and to keep the shame of your nakedness from being seen, and salve to anoint your eyes, that you may see.

 

So the question for us today is, which are we: rich, prosperous, needing nothing; or wretched, pitiable, poor, blind and naked?

 

Let’s pray...

 

 

Brave new world: the millennium

 

I’d like to read you one of my favourite poems.

 

James, James, Morrison, Morrison, Weatherby George Dupree,

Took great care of his Mother, though he was only three.

James James Said to his Mother, ‘Mother’, he said, said he,

‘You must never go down to the end of the town, if you don’t go down with me.

 

James James Morrison’s Mother put on a golden gown,

James James Morrison’s Mother drove to the end of the town.

James James Morrison’s Mother said to herself, said she,

‘I can get right down to the end of the town and be back in time for tea.’

 

King John put up a notice, ‘Lost or Stolen or Strayed!’

James James Morrison’s Mother seems to have been mislaid.

Last seen wandering vaguely, quite of her own accord,

She tried to get down to the end of the town - 40 shillings reward!

...

James James Morrison’s Mother hasn’t been heard of since.

King John said he was sorry, so did the Queen and Prince.

King John (somebody told me) said to a man he knew:

‘If people go down to the end of the town, well, what can anyone do?’

 

Now the question, is, why did she go down to the end of the town, and why was she wearing a golden gown? Well, let me tell you what I think. I think she went to see the dome. The dome’s a wonderful thing, isn’t it. I was born and brought up in the borough of Greenwich, and I’ve been watching it go up on what used to be waste dockland by the river. Nothing could be a better symbol of the dawn of a new millennium. In the dome we celebrate, at considerable expense, the glorious heights of our own achievement. In the dome we pat ourselves on the back and look into a technological future of ever greater prosperity. We have put the past behind us, and here we stand on the threshhold of a brave new world.

 

But James James Morrison Morrison’s mother didn’t come back. She set off into the settled future of an afternoon’s adventure, and yet she was last seen wandering vaguely, quite of her own accord. The settled future of the brave new world turned out to be an illusion. She got confused. A simple trip to the end of the town opened up a yawning chasm into which this middle class suburban lady disappeared for evermore. King John said he was sorry, and so did the queen and the prince; but still she has not been heard of since. For James, James Morrison Morrison’s mother, things turned out not to be as settled as she thought.

 

So what is the truth about the new millennium? Are we really advancing into a brave new world, a world of technological mastery and human achievement? As we say goodbye to modernism and embrace postmodernism, are we really entering into a world of new possibilities and ever greater individual freedom? Is that how God sees it? Or is there not perhaps something else, something more sinister, beneath the veneer of happy materialism and economic prosperity, something which only the power of God can crack open - a door which with the prophet John he wants us to go through, not wearing a golden gown, but knowing that we are wretched, pitiable, poor, blind and naked?

 

 

One hundred years ago: the Victorians and the beginning of Trinity church

 

On Friday, June 1st, 1838, the brand new Trinity church opened its doors for the first time. It opened them to the prosperous middle classes of New Walk, the Crescent in King Street, and an environment which ran from the open fields of leisure at the top of Regent Road to the crowded industrial housing at the bottom. It was founded as an evangelical church, with a commitment to preaching the word of God and a call to all its members to minister the gospel. And so as the crinolined members of the Victorian establishment emerged from their carriages to sit in their named pews, they were asked to give money to alleviate the living conditions of the poor. This is the Bolton Report of 1842: ‘anything like the squalid misery, the slow, mouldering, putrefying death by which the weak and feeble of the working classes are perishing here, it never befell eyes to behold nor imagination to conceive’.  In Leicester whole families  worked for up to 15 hours a day in the stocking trade, and still depended on Poor Relief to keep body and soul together. Housing was cramped, diet consisted of bread and potatoes, sewage ran in the gutters and collected in stagnant pools between the houses, and education and medicine were far off dreams. Infant mortality was 25%, epidemics rife.

 

And in midst of all this our predecessors did their best. Trinity set up a school, and a servants’ Bible class, and a special service for the slum kids of Oxford St. We formed a body of Parish visitors. We issued coal, lent blankets, and sold new clothes at 2/3rds of the cost price to the poor. We supported the attempts of the Temperance movement to get the men to drink coffee instead of beer. And we issued them with tracts. But still we lived and moved in the world of Jane Austen and Anthony Trollope, trying to bring relief to those who were born into the pages of Charles Dickens and Mrs Gaskell. We alleviated the suffering of the poor, but we did nothing to change it. Why; because we were stuck in our culture. England was a society of two nations, the rich and the poor. The rich were rich only because the poor were poor; and they had too much to lose for radical action. A generation earlier, at the beginning of the Evangelical movement, Wilberforce had called for what he called ‘real Christianity’ - that is, countercultural Christianity - and given his life to the abolition of slavery. His Victorian successors were slow to follow suit with the more local evils of their own day; and ‘real Christianity’ gradually came to mean the cult of morality and respectability for which we remember them now. And so the congregation of Trinity church continued to come in their carriages, wearing velvet bonnets trimmed with ostrich feathers, silk shawls, lace collars, crinolenes and multiple petticoats; whilst working kids spent Sundays in bed so their only underclothes could be washed, and a man would get 2 months hard labour for stealing a handkerchief. They did their best; but perhaps now we can see that they never really did more than alleviate the symptoms. They were unable to look at their culture from the outside and bring the word of God into it. What they gave was charity; it wasn’t the gospel.

 

Of course we got there in the end. England is no longer two nations. We live in an age of prosperity. We’ve put in the sewers. We’ve built new houses, we’ve set up schools and passed employment acts. We’ve got electricity, we’ve won 2 world wars, we’ve founded the NHS. We now have all the things the ordinary people of Victorian times did not. We have come out of the wilderness into a plentiful land, where we enjoy fruits and good things. From want we have come to plenty.

 

 

Gospel and culture today

 

So what do we conclude. Not primarily that we should be proclaiming a social gospel. But rather that we should be trying to look with the eyes of God at our society, and see what the issue is today. For there still is an issue, there still is a God who looks down and longs for his people to come close to him. But the issue has changed. It always does. We live in a new culture. It is no longer a culture of rich and poor. It is the culture of the dome, a culture of achievement and technological security. We have built ourselves a nest of comfort. And yet perhaps it is not as safe as it seems; perhaps we too find, with James James Morrison Morrison’s mother, that it leads to confusion, and ultimately to death. It feels like a cocoon, but perhaps it is more like a glass bubble, a bubble like the bauble on a Christmas tree, shining in the darkness, glittering with golden light, but oh so fragile. Think back to John. You say, I am rich, I have prospered, and I need nothing; not knowing that you are wretched, pitiable, poor, blind and naked. That is the reality. And prosperity is the illusion. The working people of the new millennium are not to be found struggling from bread and potatoes to cholera to rags and exhaustion and an early grave. The working people of the new millennium are to be found in Dixons on a Saturday afternoon. The working people of the new millennium are housed, paid and cured of their diseases. We don’t think our needs are about life and death; we think they are about possessions. We have it all. We’ve got it cracked. We live in the age of the future, a new age. We stand on the threshhold of a brave new world. And we have the dome to prove it.

 

Or do we?

Three years ago for me the bubble burst. The door bell rang. On the step I found Tony, come to tell me Roger had been hit by a lorry on the London Road. Most of you know about it, most of you prayed with me through it. But as Roger struggled for his life in intensive care, for me the world changed.  As I cried out then to God, I found myself catapulted into a fourth dimension, into a spiritual world of intangible reality which seemed so much more real than the material one. And God responded, and I found myself in harness with him, battling against pain and death, and winning in prayer by the exercise of some kind of spiritual energy, by the power of silent words and wanting it, demanding it; and finding God spoke and I knew what he was saying, and he was with me, and with all of us.

 

It happened again in Africa, where I went last summer as part of a mission team. In Africa too the western bubble bursts. In Africa the sun rises round and red over a world of pain and need, a world where reality is not cushioned by medicines and cars and millennium parties. It’s a world of spiritual powers and needy people, a world of disease and death, a world where man seems as insignificant as the plumes of scattered smoke that rise from amongst the trees. And yet if you know him, God is there. He’s there in the air. You can feel him, touch him, breathe him. In Africa there are no props. There can be no false security. Only dependence on God. And that is why the gospel is spreading in Africa. In Africa it is obvious that they are wretched, blind, pitiable, naked and poor. In England, our whole society is based on the assumption that we are rich, and that we have prospered. That’s what the millennium was all about. And yet in our heart of hearts we know it isn’t true. The party is over. And yet nothing has changed. The pain of daily living is still there. Roger and I know that people’s lives fall apart in January; because in January the bubble of celebration bursts, and we face reality once again.

 

 

Jeremiah

 

Now it was into just such a world that God sent the prophet Jeremiah. Like us, Jeremiah stood on the threshhold of a new era. Like us, he lived at a time of economic prosperity and relative complacency. We look backwards and forwards from the year 2000; the pivot for Jeremiah was the year 587, the year in which Jerusalem fell and the people were taken into captivity in Babylon. In the period preceding that event God spoke repeated words of anguish and rebuke to a self-satisfied population which insisted on ignoring the impending danger - words which have an alarming ring of appropriateness to them as we read them today. This is how he began. Chapter 2, verses 1 to 13. [It will help if you have it open]. Now in this passage Jeremiah is making a number of points.

 

Point 1. You have come from need to prosperity. Vs 7

Point 2. You came there by the hand of God

Point 3. Now in your prosperity you have forgotten you ever needed God (vs 11), and

Point 4. You are drinking from cracked cisterns instead of from the fountain of life (vs 13).

 

So, in our material prosperity we forget our need of God. We rely on ourselves. There have been times of devotion to the gospel in this country ( look at vs 2), but now is not one of them. And yet why not? We have come from a wilderness, a land of drought and darkness, material and spiritual; and into a plentiful land (that’s vs 6 &7). But as a nation we have abandoned God, and gone after worthlessness, and so become worthless (vs 5). We have a political leadership which says all is well and builds domes to a bright new future, and PR men who congratulate them on the prosperity they have brought and reassure us that all is best in the best of all possible worlds. And a church which does not say, ‘where is the Lord’, but goes with the culture and supports the status quo (you’ll find that in vs 8).

 

The picture goes on. Verse 20. Under every high hill and under every green tree we bow down, verse 27 worshipping trees and stones. It happens at Glastonbury. It happens with crystals. It happens at Stonehenge. Verse 23 we are like a restive young camel interlacing her tracks, in her heat sniffing the wind, lustful for anything that passes by. It goes on in the town centre every day. In the pursuit of consumer goods. Happiness is sought in a full plastic bag from Toys R Us, or HMV, or PCWorld. Anything, anything, as long as we buy something. And then what. The bubble bursts, and death intrudes, like it did for me in the intensive care unit, and again in Africa. Like it does for each one of us when sooner or later we are forced to face up to the intrusion of pain, evil and death in our lives. And then anguish comes. Verse 27. ‘In the time of their trouble they say, ‘arise and save us’.’ And they find in horror that no answer comes. ‘For where are their gods, says the Lord, that they made for themselves? Let them arise, if they can save you.’ Death is an outrage. I don’t think this nation went into mourning because it loved Diana. It went into mourning because she stood for our culture, and our culture doesn’t work. When Diana died, the golden bauble fell off the Christmas tree and smashed into a thousand pieces.

 

So what do we make of our society? We have changed our gods to those of materialism and pluralism. We have forsaken the Lord, the fountain of living waters, and hewn out cisterns for ourselves, broken cisterns, cisterns that can hold no water. Our whole world is built on assumptions: assumptions about human need and human fulfilment, assumptions about Western privilege, and assumptions about reality itself - assumptions which we question no more effectively than our Victorian forebears questioned theirs.

 

 

A call to take God seriously

 

So Jeremiah’s call is a call to walk away from the false values of a culture, and take God seriously. We stand on a threshhold. The bubble is bursting. We have been drinking from cracked cisterns, cisterns of false security, of confidence in ourselves, of consumer values. The taped up certainties of the modern world are looking increasingly battered. Science has failed to explain the universe, increased prosperity seems only to have brought increased discontent, and the 3rd world is screaming at our door. This is what one commentator says: ‘our known world is under judgment and is ending, the known world of moral certitudes, technological superiority, political dominance and economic monopoly’. The task of the church is to take the gospel out of the box we allowed that world to put it into, and to listen to God’s voice afresh. For God is an awesome God. We like to comfort ourselves with the thought of God’s love in the troubles of our daily lives. But do we dare stand before God as he is, the God whom Jeremiah knows? Jeremiah knows God as the power who made the earth and established the world. Jeremiah knows a God whose word is like fire, and like a hammer which breaks the rock in pieces. Jeremiah knows a God who is hurting because we have forgotten him, and trusted in lies; a God who expects a response, and threatens to shame us by lifting our skirts up over our faces if he doesn’t get one. And yet he also knows a God who will rush to meet us if we turn to him, to restore and renew us, and to give us once more the waters of the fountain of life. All these things are in Jeremiah.

 

So what does God want of this Jeremiah to whom he speaks so clearly? Jeremiah’s job is to paint a different picture, to free us from the dominant values of our culture. Jeremiah is a poet. He does not write in prose, to explain it to us, to tell us what to do. He writes in verse, to inspire us. He writes to give us a vision of a God who is big, bigger than the God of the conventional religious tradition, and certainly bigger than the secular God of the dome. He writes to open our minds to possibility, the possibility of stepping out of a false world and into the unseen world of spiritual reality, the world of acknowledged pain and yet the world of untold possibility. He invites us to move with God from the old modern culture of certainty into a new postmodern world of changing values.

 

 

Where then are you?

 

How then are we to respond to Jeremiah? I think in the same way that he speaks to us. Think of your life as a painting. You have a broad canvas, on which all the elements of your daily life are painted against the backcloth of our culture. The dome is there, the Shires is there, the leisure centre is there; the Houses of Parliament and the M25 and Microsoft and Channel Five. And in there somewhere are you, with your family or your friends, your job and your car, your cell group and this church. Now round that painting is a frame. It’s a nice frame, a strong wooden one, tinged a pleasant shade of blue. The only problem with it is, it doesn’t fit the picture very well, because the picture keeps wriggling. Little ripples of tension run across the canvas, and the frame shifts, and minute cracks appear. You try not to notice. Every so often you adjust it, hoping no one will see you. But it’s getting worse.

 

So what do you do? If you listen to the unspoken assumptions of the world around you, you will continue to fiddle and adjust. But Jeremiah offers you a new possibility. Jeremiah’s bombshell is that you need to throw that frame away. The world is changing, the picture won’t keep still any more, and it is God himself who is trying to get out of the cracks.

 

So if you want to listen to Jeremiah, and you’re willing to throw away the frame, the next thing you need to do is ask, where am I in the story? You could be in one of two places. You could be amongst the people to whom God speaks, drinking from cracked cisterns, worshipping the idols of our culture, idols whom God says have no more solidity than scarecrows in a cucumber field. These are the idols of the visible. The idols of material comfort and of illusory control. They are the idols of a tamed God who can be relied on to give you good things, and of a faith which lives in a compartment. The idols of the dome, idols of mastery, control and security. The idols of choice and leisure and affluence.

 

And if that’s you, Jeremiah calls you to return to the living God, to the fountain of living waters. He calls you to acknowledge pain, to face up to uncertainty, to give up the illusion of independence for the reality of dependence on God. He calls you to step out of the visible world of static certainties, and to embrace the moving canvas which has no edges. He calls you to engage with God, and to ask him what he wants of you in the shifting sands of the postmodern world.

 

But perhaps that’s not where you are. Perhaps you find yourself not with the people and their cracked cisterns, but with Jeremiah himself. Perhaps you are called to speak words of warning and of life, to envision a new world, to offer access to the fountain of living waters to other people. We fight shy of offering the gospel to other people, because to do it is in itself a countercultural act. We like to fit in. We like to conform. We don’t like to take risks. But the people out there are drinking from cracked cisterns and struggling to keep the wooden frame of their lives in place. They need the gospel. They are searching for it, in all the ways our new age makes possible. But they are searching in the wrong places. Later on Jeremiah talks about two sorts of people. The shrub in the desert, withered and parched. Or the tree planted by water, which does not fear when heat comes, for its leaves remain green and it continues to bear fruit. We do have something to offer, an answer to human hurt and to human hope, a reality to replace the illusion. What we have to offer is life itself.

 

Conclusion

 

So behold, I stand at the door and knock. If anyone hears my voice and opens the door, I will come in to him and eat with him, and he with me. 

For you say, I am rich, I have prospered, and I need nothing; not knowing that you are wretched, pitiable, poor, blind and naked. Therefore I counsel you to buy from me gold refined by fire, that you may be rich, and white garments to clothe you and to keep the shame of your nakedness from being seen, and salve to anoint your eyes, that you may see.

Amen.